How to Choose a Plumber: 9 Checks That Go Beyond the Star Rating
You are choosing a plumber in one of two situations. Either water is coming through a ceiling right now, or the job can wait a week and you have time to compare. Which checks you can run depends on which one you are in. I am Serhii Ksonzenko, founder of USD.org.
The Short Answer
Here is the whole method:
- Find out the legal name of the company that will arrive, plus its license number.
- Look the license up in the official registry and match the name against the quote.
- Get proof of insurance from the insurer, and confirm the policy is still active.
- Treat the stars as a report on the visit. On permit work, check the permit record.
- Get the price in writing. Write into the contract that the last payment is due after the work is done and, if a permit was involved, after the final inspection passes.
Around St. Petersburg, we found an active license on 22 of 39 pages with a 5.0 rating, and on 24 of 28 pages rated 4.8 to 4.9 (our study). A license we could not find does not prove the company has none.
How Much Checking Can Your Problem Wait For?
| Your situation | Check without fail | Can skip for now |
|---|---|---|
| Water will not stop, or waste water is entering the house | Company name, license number, trip fee, written price before extra work | Multiple quotes, permit history |
| Water is shut off, but no hot water or one fixture is dead | License registry, calls to two companies, prices | Deep permit research |
| Planned work, no rush | All nine checks, two or three written quotes | Nothing |
If water is running, start with the box below.
If water is running right now
- If you smell gas, leave the house and call 911 from outside. If anyone is hurt, or you see sparks or smoke, call 911.
- Shut the main valve, if you can reach it without walking through water near outlets, cords, or the electrical panel. Our pipe burst guide walks through this step by step: What to Do When a Pipe Bursts.
- If you can reach it without wading, turn the water heater's gas control to Off. If it is electric, switch off its breaker only if the floor, the panel and your hands are dry. If the water heater stood in water, do not use it, and have a plumber check it.
- On the phone, ask for four things: the company's legal name, the license number, the trip fee and any after-hours fee, and a texted price before work starts.
- I would also set a cap on the first visit, a not-to-exceed amount that covers just stopping the emergency.
- If the water is off and the room is safe, ask the plumber whether the repair can wait until regular business hours.
None of the 56 companies around St. Petersburg we checked in October 2026 published an after-hours rate, so you have to ask by phone (our price check).
1. Find Out Who Actually Answers the Phone
Some listings lead to a middleman that passes your job to a contractor you never chose. Many operate legally, but you do not know who will show up, who sets the price, and who answers for the result.
In our sample of 200 websites around St. Petersburg, checked in October 2026, 10 belonged to middlemen styled to look like a local firm (our check).
How to Spot a Middleman lists eight checks, from reading the site footer and terms for the words referral service, lead generation, or independent contractors, to comparing the phone number in the listing with the one on the company's own site.
Then ask the direct question: "Do you do the work yourselves, or send the job to another company?" When the technician arrives, compare the name on the truck, the quote, and the invoice.
2. Look Up the License Yourself
The word "licensed" on a homepage proves nothing by itself. Of 82 sites we reviewed, 23 claimed a license without showing a number. Fifteen of those had an active license in the registry. For the other 8 we found no active license under the name we had (our check, October 2026). You have to look.
Does Your State License Plumbers?
Licensing rules come from states and local governments. Most states require a license, and some cities and counties add their own requirements (BLS). If your state does not license plumbers, ask the building department of your city or county. Where no license is required, insurance and permit records carry more of the weight.
What to Match on the Record
Ask for the number, then match four things on the record:
- The status is current and active.
- The name on the record matches the name on your quote.
- The license type covers your kind of work.
- The license is valid in your city or county.
What if the search comes back empty? That is still not proof of no license. At least 6 of the 76 listings where we found a license held it under a different business name (our study). Try searching by the number instead.
Jobs That May Not Need a License
The list of exempt work depends on the state. Of 17 five-star pages where we found no license, six belonged to specialists in drain cleaning, camera inspection, leak detection, and pipe tapping, work that may need no license (our study). If a drain specialist tells you the pipe needs replacing, that new job needs a license check again.
Florida
Florida issues the statewide CFC certification and the RF registration, which is valid only where the contractor holds a local license (F.S. 489.105). You can check either one for free in the state's Verify a Licensee portal, looking for Current, Active or Probation, Active; probation means the company can still work but is under a disciplinary action, so ask why. Our full walkthrough: How to Check a Plumber's License in Florida.
3. Get Proof of Insurance From the Source
Ask about two coverages. General liability pays for damage to your home and to people on your property. Workers' compensation covers the technician if they get hurt on your job.
If a contractor without workers' compensation has a worker injured inside your home, the homeowner can end up responsible. A standard homeowner policy may not cover contractor-caused damage. The example is from New Hampshire, and other states differ (New Hampshire Insurance Department).
"I'm insured" is not proof. Ask for a certificate sent by the insurer or the insurance agent. A certificate is only a summary, and a policy can be canceled after it is issued. Call the insurer named on the certificate and confirm the policy is active. On the document itself, check the company name and the validity dates. A license does not imply insurance.
Florida
Florida requires workers' compensation in construction with as few as one employee, though some co-owners can claim an exemption (F.S. 440.02). Both coverage and exemptions are checkable for free in the state's Proof of Coverage and Exemption portals.
4. What Reviews Can Show
A review tells the story of a visit. Did the plumber arrive on time, fix the problem, and charge what was promised?
Count the Reviews Before the Stars
Twelve of the 39 pages rated 5.0 in our St. Petersburg sample rest on five reviews or fewer. Three rest on a single review. Among those twelve, we found an active license on only four (our study).
Read the one-star reviews and the recent ones, and look for the name of the company or the person who actually came. A rating belongs to a page, and a middleman's page can collect reviews about many different contractors.
What Reviews Can't Tell You
Pipes end up inside a wall. A customer rarely sees the joints behind the tile. The record that survives is the inspection record, and reviews do not contain it.
Around Tampa Bay, we compared 38 companies and their 999 final inspections (our study). Companies with more reviews than the sample's median of 57 passed 71% of their final inspections on the first try. Those at or below it passed 84%. The gap held within each city or county and, where the portals record it, within each type of permit.
This does not mean companies with more reviews do worse work. The data does not show the reasons, and the spread inside each group is wide. Look at the permit record of the specific company you are about to hire.
What stars show, and what the public record shows
A review describes a visit. A permit record describes the work.
| What you want to know | Reviews | Permit record |
|---|---|---|
| Someone arrived on time | Can describe it | No |
| The bill matched the price | Can describe it | No |
| The hidden work passed its rough-in inspection | Seldom covers it | Yes, with a date |
| The final inspection passed | Seldom covers it | Yes, with a date |
| The same company's record over years | Only as long as the page lasts | Searchable by license number or company name |
| Which contractor did the work | A middleman's page can mix several | The permit usually names the contractor |
USD.org, November 2026.
5. Check the Work on Public Record
Permit records are public, and in many places they are online and free. On permitted jobs, this record tells you whether the work passed inspection.
Which jobs usually need a permit? Water heater replacement, repiping, water and sewer line work, fixture relocation, and gas lines. Drain cleaning and small leak repairs usually do not (IRC R105.2). Your building department gives the final answer.
How to Find a Company's Permits
- Work out who issues permits in your area, the city or the county.
- Search by license number where the portal offers it. If you search by name, try every spelling. One company in St. Petersburg appears under three different names in the portal (our study).
- Look for recent jobs like yours, and for closed permits with a passed final inspection.
- Watch for patterns: many expired permits, or a final inspection that never happened.
What did the records show? In St. Petersburg, 446 of 561 final inspections passed on the first attempt, which is 80%. Among 24 companies with ten or more inspections, the pass rate ranged from 58% to 100% (our study, October 2026).
The gap by review count is not a neat line
Share of final inspections passed on the first try, by how many reviews the company has. 38 companies and 999 final inspections around Tampa Bay, October 2026.
- Passed on the first try
- Up to 20 reviews11 companies
- 21 to 100 reviews14 companies
- 101 to 500 reviews6 companies
- Over 500 reviews7 companies
| Reviews | Companies | Passed first time |
|---|---|---|
| Up to 20 | 11 | 81.8% |
| 21 to 100 | 14 | 86.4% |
| 101 to 500 | 6 | 73.2% |
| Over 500 | 7 | 68.1% |
| Total | 38 | 74.8% |
USD.org, permit portals and map listings, October 2026. The overall first-try rate across all 999 final inspections is 74.8%; the 80% above is the separate St. Petersburg sample. Partial results do not count.
One failed inspection is common: in St. Petersburg, about one final in five failed the first time, 115 of 561 (our study). What matters is that the error got fixed. An expired permit can mean a canceled order. A company may do most of its work in other jurisdictions. A new company simply has few records.
Florida
On the Tampa and county permit portals, each permit names the Licensed Professional and the license number (our study). You can take that number straight into the state registry.
6. Compare Written Quotes Line by Line
The FTC's advice is to get several written quotes describing the work, materials, schedule, and price (FTC). Do not grab the lowest number automatically. If one quote is far off from the rest, ask why.
What Every Quote Should Spell Out
Lay the quotes side by side and check the same rows on each:
| Row | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Company name and license number | The name must match the registry record |
| Scope of work | Defines what is included |
| Equipment model and parts | "Water heater" is not a model number |
| Permit and re-inspection fees | Someone has to pay for them |
| Removal of old equipment | Often billed separately |
| Wall or floor restoration | Repiping leaves holes |
| Trip fee and whether it is credited | A $149 fee may or may not count toward the repair |
| Warranty on labor and parts | Terms in writing, with duration |
| Start and finish dates | A schedule you can hold them to |
| What could change the price | The escape hatch, stated up front |
What Plumbers Publish as Prices
Here is what companies around St. Petersburg showed on their websites on October 14 and 15, 2026. Treat these as orientation points. Prices change (our price check).
Only 14 of 56 companies publish any price for plumbing work, so in most cases you will have to ask. Where a trip or diagnostic fee was published (five companies), it ranged from $65 to $149. A standard tank water heater, on five sites, starts between $1,150 and $1,895 installed; ask whether the permit and the old unit's removal are included. Of the 42 companies with no plumbing prices, 21 advertise a free estimate. Ask whether it is free for your job: one company charges a minimum estimate fee of $79 or $89.
Hourly, Flat Rate or Not-to-Exceed
A flat rate holds as long as the job is what was described. On hourly work, I would ask how many hours the job usually takes and whether drive time is billed. On any open-ended job, I would ask for a not-to-exceed cap that the plumber cannot pass without your approval.
A "$99 a month" offer is a loan. Ask for the full cash price and the total of all payments before signing anything.
Whatever was promised by phone, get it into the contract. Do not leave blank spaces in a signed document.
7. What to Ask on the First Call
| Ask about | Good answer | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Which company will come, and who is responsible | A named company, the same one that will appear on the quote | "A local partner" |
| The license number | Recited on the spot | "We're licensed" with no number |
| The trip fee and whether it counts toward the repair | An exact sum and the condition | "We'll see when we get there" |
| Evenings, weekends, holidays | A stated surcharge, or a stated absence of one | Refusal to answer |
| A written price before work begins | Yes | "Just trust us" |
| Permits and who files the application | "We file it, and you'll have the number before we start" | An offer to file it in your name |
| Warranty on labor and parts | Duration and terms, in writing | No conditions offered |
| Their most recent failed inspection and the fix (for permitted work) | A concrete description | "Inspections are just a formality" |
8. Signs You Should Walk Away
- Pressure to decide immediately.
- Full payment up front, or cash only.
- The contractor appeared uninvited because it "was in the neighborhood," or offers leftover materials from another job.
- A request to pull the permit in your own name. That can make you responsible for the work.
- Refusal to show proof of insurance.
- No company name given, and no license number for licensed work.
- An offer to connect you with "their" lender.
One more protection kicks in once you sign. The federal Cooling-Off Rule gives three business days to cancel many home purchases of $25 or more (FTC). It has exceptions for a repair you asked the seller to come and do and for a genuine emergency, each with conditions (16 CFR 429.0). Which one applies depends on the facts, and extras sold during the visit stay covered. So if a leak call turns into a pitch to replace your whole system, that is a separate decision. Ask for a written price and take your time.
9. Paying a Plumber
Do not pay everything up front. Some states cap the advance a contractor may take, so check with your state agency (FTC).
Pay by card or check, so a record exists. Approve any additional work in writing before it is done. Before you sign, write into the contract that the last payment is due after the work is done and, if a permit was involved, after the final inspection passes. Then check the result in the portal yourself rather than relying on a photo of the inspection card. On work that will be hidden behind a wall, ask whether the inspection happens before the covering goes on. Write in who pays for repeat inspections.
Keep everything: the contract, invoices, photos, messages, the permit, and the warranty (USA.gov).
Florida
If the first payment on home improvement work exceeds 10% of the contract price, the contractor must apply for permits within 30 days and start work within 90 days of permit issuance, absent just cause or your written consent to a longer period (F.S. 489.126). Above $2,500 the owner must record a Notice of Commencement, and paying after it lapses can mean paying twice (F.S. 713.13).
If the Job Goes Wrong
Getting the Work Fixed
Go to the contractor first (FTC). Follow the phone call with a letter sent by certified mail with return receipt, and keep copies. Pull together the contract, receipts, photos, and messages.
If an inspection failed, ask the inspector for the written defect notice. Write down what will be corrected, who pays for it, and when the re-inspection happens.
If no permit was pulled at all, call your building department and ask what it requires at your stage of the work: not started, in progress, or already done. If the contractor has vanished, ask the permit office how to close the permit with a different contractor.
Who to Complain To
Start with the licensing agency of your state or city. Your state consumer protection office takes the next complaint; USA.gov lists them all. The state attorney general and local consumer offices handle home improvement complaints. For outright fraud, file at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
If none of that resolves it, look for free or low-cost legal aid in your area (USA.gov).
Florida
DBPR takes complaints through its Construction Industry form, and its Unlicensed Activity Hotline is 1-866-532-1440 (DBPR). The Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services takes consumer complaints at 1-800-HELP-FLA (FDACS).
Pick a Plumber Before You Need One
The best time for all nine checks is while nothing is leaking. Save two numbers in your phone: your water utility's emergency line, and a plumber you have already vetted. Find your main shut-off valve today. Re-check the plumber's license and phone number once a year; companies and addresses change. A small first job, like a faucet repair, shows how a company keeps its word.
How I Put This Together
The numbers in this article come from USD.org's published checks of plumbers around St. Petersburg and Tampa Bay in October 2026, and each figure links to the study behind it. Federal and state recommendations are cited to their original sources, and I list every source with its check date at the end. The method has limits: one region, public sources only, and a license we could not find does not mean none exists. USD.org is a directory of local companies, and permit records are one of the factors in our published method. We do not sell plumbing services, and nobody paid for this article. I am not a plumber and not a lawyer, and I accept corrections.
FAQ
How do I know if a plumber is good?
Match the license to the quote in the official registry, then read the company's permit record for passed final inspections. Reviews add what you cannot see elsewhere: punctuality and the final bill.
How do I avoid getting ripped off by a plumber?
Get the price in writing before work starts, never pay in full up front, and pay by card or check. Walk away from pressure tactics, cash-only demands, and anyone who wants the permit in your name.
What should I do before I call a plumber?
If you smell gas, leave the house and call 911 from outside. Shut the main valve if you can reach it safely. Then ask by phone for the company name, the license number, the trip fee, and a texted price before work begins.
How many quotes should I get?
Two or three written quotes for planned work. For an emergency, one written price is enough, plus the license check.
Should I pay a plumber up front?
Never the full amount. Some states cap advances, and the final payment should wait until the work is done, and until the final inspection passes if a permit was involved. Write the last-payment condition into the contract before you sign.
Do plumbers need a license in every state?
Most states license plumbers, but not all. Some states leave it to cities or counties.
What if I can't find a plumber's license?
A failed search is not proof of no license. The company may hold it under a different name, so search by the number. If it still does not turn up, ask the plumber directly for the number and the issuing agency.
What do plumbers not tell you up front?
Who will actually arrive, whether the trip fee counts toward the repair, and whether the job needs a permit. All three answers should be in your written quote.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Laws and agency practices change. For a decision about your own project or dispute, check the current law or talk to a licensed attorney. It also does not replace help from a licensed plumber, your utility or emergency services when safety is at risk.
If you spot an error, especially if you are a licensed plumber, write to [email protected].
Sources
- USD.org studies: Does a 5-Star Rating Mean a Licensed Plumber? (ratings October 1, registry October 26, 2026); Do Plumbers With More Reviews Pass Inspection More Often? (reviews October 1, portals early October 2026); Did Your Plumber Pull a Permit? (portals October 13 and 14, counties October 9 to 13, 2026); How to Spot a Middleman (200 sites, October 1 to 21, 2026); What St. Petersburg Plumbers Charge (56 companies, October 14 and 15, 2026); Why We Show License Numbers (82 sites, October 1, 2026); How to Check a Plumber's License in Florida (checked October 9, 2026); What to Do When a Pipe Bursts (checked November 10, 2026).
- Federal Trade Commission: How To Avoid a Home Improvement Scam (checked November 9, 2026); Cooling-Off Rule (checked November 9, 2026); 16 CFR Part 429 (checked November 9, 2026); ReportFraud.ftc.gov (checked October 27 and 28, 2026).
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics: Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters (checked November 9, 2026).
- USA.gov: complaints and state consumer protection offices (checked November 9, 2026).
- New Hampshire Insurance Department (checked November 9, 2026).
- 2024 International Residential Code, Chapter 1 (checked October 15, 2026).
- Florida Statutes, 2026 edition: 489.105 (checked November 9, 2026); 489.126 (checked November 9, 2026); 440.02 (checked November 9, 2026); 713.13 (checked November 9, 2026).
- Florida DBPR: Verify a Licensee, complaint form, hurricane season guide (checked November 9, 2026).
- Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services: complaint form (checked November 9, 2026).
- Florida Department of Financial Services: Proof of Coverage and Exemption (checked November 9, 2026).