Skip to content

Do Plumbers With More Reviews Pass Inspection More Often? I Checked Almost 1,000 Final Inspections Around Tampa Bay

I could not find anyone comparing plumber reviews with inspection records. So I built the comparison myself, from almost 1,000 final inspections.

You have two plumbers to choose from. One has a thousand reviews, the other a few dozen. The job is a water heater, a repipe, a sewer line or a bathroom remodel. Much of the work ends up behind a wall after the rough-in inspection, and the inspection record is the one account that stays.

This article is about the inspection your city or county runs under a permit. Two other checks share the name and crowd the search results. One is a home inspection before a sale. The other is a routine camera look at your pipes.

A review describes a visit: how the company answered the phone, how the tech acted, what the bill looked like. An inspector looks at the work and compares it with the building code.

I matched the reviews of local plumbing companies to their final inspection results. Then I worked out how to check one company.

I run USD.org, which ranks local businesses using an open methodology. I am not a plumber or a lawyer.

The Short Answer

In our sample, no. Companies with more than 57 reviews passed their first final inspection 71% of the time. Companies with 57 or fewer passed 84% of the time. The gap stayed after I adjusted for the jurisdiction and, as far as the portals allow, the type of permit.

Among the completed permits I sampled, 97.4% passed in the end, so a failed final there usually meant a delay. I picked completed permits, so this number leans high and leaves out abandoned jobs.

More reviews do not mean a worse company. The group numbers also do not choose a plumber for you. Check that company's own records.

How to Compare Two Plumbers Before You Hire

Six checks. The first two are quick. The rest help you read what the records show.

1. Use reviews for what they can tell you

A review tells you about the visit: whether someone arrived on time, explained the price, and cleaned up after. The finished work is what an inspector reads. A perfect average built on three reviews is thin. The same average on three hundred reviews is not. I keep the details in Does a 5-Star Rating Mean a Licensed Plumber?.

2. Open the right permit portal

Work out who issues the permit for your address: your city or your county. Only one of them keeps the record, and only its portal shows the inspections. Did Your Plumber Pull a Permit? shows how to find a company by name and read what comes back.

3. Count at least ten plumbing finals in one jurisdiction

Search the company name and open its plumbing permits. Count the final inspections, and count how many passed the first time. Divide the second number by the first. A rough share is enough here. Then look separately at the permits for work like yours: water heaters, drains, repipes, water lines.

No results does not mean no permits. Try other spellings of the name or call the permits office.

Say a company shows ten final plumbing inspections in the last two years. Eight passed the first time and two did not. That is 80%.

Ten is a floor to work from. In our sample, single companies ran from 59% to 100% of finals passing first time. A small set swings hard: on ten records you cannot tell 80% from 70%. Stay with the most recent records, because a company changes crews over the years.

4. Compare a company with the local baseline

On our numbers, about one final plumbing inspection in four fails the first time. The share that passed first time ran from 63% to 81% across the four jurisdictions. An 80% run is normal, then. One failed final says little on its own.

Compare companies inside one jurisdiction. Portals word their statuses differently, and a Pinellas label does not line up with a Tampa one. A permit with two or three failed finals is worth a question. A final that never closed is worth two.

5. Ask three questions

  • Who calls the inspector, and do you check the work before the call?
  • What was your last failed final, and what did you change after it?
  • Who pays for the fix and the next inspection?

The third answer is the one people skip. Ask for it in writing and put it in the contract. Then the price of a mistake is clear before someone makes one.

6. Check the license

The permit record shows the work, and the state record shows the company. Both are free. The state also requires the license number on bids, contracts and ads. How to Check a Plumber's License in Florida walks through the search step by step.

What I Found

I gathered 38 plumbing companies and their 999 final plumbing inspections across St. Petersburg, Pinellas, Tampa and Hillsborough. For each company I took its review count. I matched it to the first result of every final inspection on its permits.

The line holds near the top, then steps down.

Companies with up to 100 reviews passed 84.2% of their first finals. Companies with more than 100 passed 69.3%. The step sits around 100 reviews.

Companies with more than 100 reviews passed the first final inspection less often

Share of final plumbing inspections that passed on the first try, by the company’s number of reviews. Hover or tap a bar for the counts.

  • Up to 20 reviews
  • 21 to 100 reviews
  • 101 to 500 reviews
  • More than 500 reviews

Covers 38 plumbing companies and 999 final plumbing inspections on completed permits in St. Petersburg, Pinellas, Tampa and Hillsborough. Source: USD.org, city and county permit portals, collected in early October 2026; review counts shown by a popular online maps service on October 1, 2026.

In bands the same shape shows up. Up to 20 reviews, 81.8%. Twenty-one to 100, 86.4%. One hundred one to 500, 73.2%. More than 500, 68.1%. The bands do not fall in order, and the drops between them are uneven.

The direction holds in all four jurisdictions. In each one, companies with more reviews passed less often than companies with fewer.

Their portals label outcomes differently, and the mix of work differs, so I do not rank the jurisdictions against each other. On its own, "Tampa is stricter than St. Petersburg" would be too strong a claim.

Work types point the same way in seven of the eight groups I could split. Water heaters, drains, a repipe and county trade permits all show the gap. These groups are small, so I read them as a hint.

Star ratings do not make a straight line either. Companies rated 5.0 passed 85.4%. Companies at 4.8 or 4.9 passed 70.0%, below the group under them at 79.9%. A 5.0 often rests on a handful of reviews, so that band mixes quality with volume.

Across companies the spread is wide. Of the 28 with ten or more finals, companies above the median passed between 59% and 89% of first finals. Those below passed between 60% and 100%. The ranges overlap. The group pattern tells you where to look, and the company record tells you who to hire.

The county numbers here run lower than in my earlier article about permits (70.5% against 78%), because that sample included a county whose results are labeled differently. St. Petersburg is about the same (81% and 80%).

Does a Failed Inspection Mean You Have a Bad Plumber?

No. Most first failures get fixed. Of the 999 finals in the sample, 97.4% passed in the end. Fifty-four permits needed three final inspections or more. The sample holds completed permits only, so jobs abandoned before a final are not in it.

For you, a failed final means a wait. In a wider set of our records that also takes in companies without reviews, 407 first failures later passed. The stretch from failure to pass had a median of 7 days, and 18.4% of those stretches ran past a month. These are low estimates, because failures that never closed are not counted.

Our records do not say why an inspection failed. The status line does not carry the reason. Ask for the inspector's written correction notice, or call the permits office and ask what the record shows. A plumber who has the notice in hand and can explain the fix is worth talking to.

What a plumbing inspector checks

The plumbing inspection runs in stages, and the stage decides what there is to see. A rough-in comes before the walls close, and it covers what you will not see again: drain, waste and vent piping, pipe slope, and a pressure test. The final comes at the end, once the building is complete and the fixtures are connected. By then the walls are closed, so it covers what is still in reach: the water heater vent, strap and pan, the shut-off, the T&P drain, and the cleanouts.

The plumbing code sets the list, and it runs long. I have no count of my own for which items come up most, so treat this as the shape of it.

What is worth a second look

A failed final on one permit is common. Two other things are worth a question.

A permit that needed three final inspections or more. In our sample that was 54 of 999. It may mean the first fix missed the cause.

A final that never closes. The job passed rough-in, failed final, and the record sits open with no follow-up. A stalled final can also come from the customer's side. Ask the company what happened. For reference, Florida lists working on a job without the required permits and inspections among the grounds to discipline a contractor (F.S. 489.129).

Why More Reviews Might Go With More Failed Finals

I cannot prove a cause from this data on Tampa Bay companies. A few explanations fit what I see.

A company with many reviews may be busier. It may run more crews, and more crews can mean more hands on the work and less of an owner on site. A wider mix of jobs may also reach further into the harder end: repipes, sewer work, commercial calls.

The rhythm of the work can differ. A small company may test its own work and fix it before calling the inspector. A large one may rely more on the inspection as a step in the schedule.

The timing of reviews matters too. Most are written right after the visit, and the final inspection often comes later. The rating and the final answer different questions, at different moments.

I did test the easy explanations. The gap held when I compared companies in the same jurisdiction. It held within permit types. It held with the three largest companies dropped, and under a stricter count that treats a partial pass as a failure. One company or one county is not carrying the result.

Three things I cannot test: how hard each job was, how each inspector runs a site, and who was on the crew that day.

So treat it as a pattern rather than a rule. The data does not show that more reviews make the work worse, or that a large company is a bad company. It shows that the review count is a weak guide to the final inspection.

The same weak link shows up outside plumbing. In other fields, online ratings line up only loosely with an objective measure. Everyday product ratings matched objective test results in about 57% of cases in one study (Journal of Consumer Research, 2016). Chance alone would give about 50%. Online ratings for heart surgeons barely moved with their patients' outcomes in another (JMIR, 2016). Neither studied plumbers, so take it as a hint.

If Your Plumber's Inspection Fails

A failed final is a normal step. What you do in the next week matters more than the failure.

Start with the notice. Ask your plumber for the inspector's written correction notice, if there is one. A summary over the phone will not do. If your plumber will not show it, ask the permits office for the record.

Then keep the stages in order. A final comes last, after the walls are closed and the fixtures are set, so the fix is usually in reach. The rule that bites sits one step back, at rough-in. Work should not be covered before the inspector approves it. Drywall, tile and backfill can bury a defect and turn a small fix into a demolition. Section 110.6 puts that on the contractor: work must not go past an inspection point before the building official approves it (Florida Building Code, Section 110.6).

Get it in writing. What gets fixed, who pays, and when the next inspection is booked. A text is better than nothing, but check what your contract requires for changes.

Who pays

Two costs sit here, and people blend them. The repair itself, and the fee for the next inspection. The failure alone assigns neither.

The repair answers to the cause and to your contract. If the plumber installed the work wrong, the repair is often on the plumber, depending on your contract. If you changed the plan mid-job, the extra may be on you. Read the contract for who carries a re-inspection.

On the fee, Florida sets a rule. After a first inspection and one re-inspection for the same violation, the price changes. Each further re-inspection costs four times the bigger of those two fees (F.S. 553.80). In our records, 12% of first failures on the county and Tampa portals carry a fee mark. The amount is local, so ask your building department.

Before the last payment, open the portal and check the result of the re-inspection. The record shows whether the final passed. The check is free and it takes a minute.

If your plumber stalls or walks away

You can call the permits office and ask what it takes to close the permit with someone else. You can also file a complaint with the state (DBPR complaint form). If the company was licensed and abandoned the job or caused certain financial harm, a homeowner who lives in the house may be able to claim from the state's Homeowners' Construction Recovery Fund. You first need a court judgment, arbitration award or board order, and you must try other ways to collect. For a plumbing contractor, the cap is $30,000 on contracts signed since July 2024 (F.S. 489.141 and 489.143).

How This Study Was Done

The inspection data comes from four permit portals, collected in early October 2026: St. Petersburg, Pinellas, Hillsborough and Tampa. Reviews come from a popular online maps service, read on October 1, 2026.

For each company I took the first result of every final plumbing inspection on its permits, up to 25 completed applications. A permit with no final inspection did not count. A first attempt is the first final result on a permit. A pass is Approved, Pass or Approved with Conditions. A fail is Disapproved, Correction Notice, Fail or Not Ready. Partial results do not count.

To compare fairly, I adjusted the two groups for the jurisdiction and, as far as the portals allow, the type of permit. The exact kind of job is known mostly for St. Petersburg permits. Under a stricter count, where a partial pass and a same-day retry both read as a fail, the gap held.

Some limits are worth stating. I picked completed permits with a final inspection, so jobs abandoned before a final are not counted. The Pasco portal labels results in a way that does not compare with the rest, so for our purposes it is out. The St. Petersburg portal finds a company by name. For 33 of 82 companies the name search returned nothing, so some local companies are not here.

The reviews were read after some of the inspections, so an older job can carry today's review count.

This is a correlation across 38 companies. It does not account for how hard each job was or how each inspector works.

Only totals appear here, no company names. A company can write to us and ask us to recheck its numbers.

USD.org is itself a directory. No one paid for this article, and we do not sell plumbing work. Permit records are also one factor in how USD.org scores businesses.

FAQ

Do plumbers with more reviews do better work?

On the records, companies with more reviews passed first finals less often. That does not show the work is worse: a first-time result is one narrow measure.

How can I tell if a plumber is good?

Check the license, then count the company's own final inspections on the portal and compare them with the local baseline. Reviews come after that.

What is a first-time inspection pass rate?

The share of final inspections that pass on the first visit. In our sample it was about 75%.

How many inspections do I need to judge a plumber?

Ten plumbing finals in one jurisdiction is a fair start. Below that, one or two results swing the share.

Does a failed plumbing inspection mean the plumber did bad work?

Usually no. In our sample of completed permits, most failures were fixed and passed. The same failure repeating is the stronger sign.

Who pays for a re-inspection in Florida?

The repair and the inspection fee are separate. A failed final alone decides neither. Your contract and the cause do. Ask your building department what the fee is.

Can I see a plumber's inspection history for free?

Yes, on the city or county permit portal. The searches I used need no account.

Should I ignore online reviews?

No. Use them for the visit and the service. For the work, use the permit record.

The numbers describe our sample, not any one plumber.

This article is general information about Florida law, not legal advice. Laws and agency practices change. For a decision about your own project or dispute, check the current law or talk to a Florida-licensed attorney.

A licensed plumber or an inspector who reads this can send corrections to [email protected].

Sources

Checked on the dates shown.